{ "schema_version": 1, "checked_at": "2026-09-26T20:26:11.571909Z", "version": "0.1.1", "snapshot_kind": "manual-audit", "tests": { "passed": 26, "failed": 0, "scope": "Researcher deterministic test suite" }, "runtime": { "aios": "not-running-at-check", "ollama": "not-running-at-check", "web_research": "not-run", "oracle": "capacity-inspected-billing-unverified" }, "run": { "run_id": "status-local-20260926", "engine": "local", "status": "succeeded", "duration_ms": 152, "finished_at": "2026-09-26T20:26:11.571909Z" }, "question": "What does the local evidence say about identity persistence?", "sources": [ { "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-dda963ce", "title": "Identity Persistence Working Notes", "source_type": "local-md" }, { "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-e9130704", "title": "Counterarguments", "source_type": "local-md" }, { "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-b554fff0", "title": "Babel Researcher stores evidence excerpts separately from claims.", "source_type": "local-txt" } ], "evidence": [ { "evidence_id": "EV-LOCAL-dda963ce-0001", "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-dda963ce", "excerpt": "# Identity Persistence Working Notes", "location": "line 1", "exact_quote": true }, { "evidence_id": "EV-LOCAL-dda963ce-0007", "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-dda963ce", "excerpt": "Useful tests include preference stability, reason consistency, response to contradiction, and the ability to explain why a belief changed.", "location": "line 7", "exact_quote": true }, { "evidence_id": "EV-LOCAL-dda963ce-0009", "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-dda963ce", "excerpt": "Identity should include protected commitments, revisable beliefs, autobiographical memory, and a record of meaningful transitions.", "location": "line 9", "exact_quote": true }, { "evidence_id": "EV-LOCAL-e9130704-0005", "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-e9130704", "excerpt": "A complete event history can create the appearance of identity while burying causal structure under irrelevant memory.", "location": "line 5", "exact_quote": true }, { "evidence_id": "EV-LOCAL-e9130704-0003", "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-e9130704", "excerpt": "Excessive continuity can make an artificial identity brittle. A system that never revises itself is persistent but not adaptive.", "location": "line 3", "exact_quote": true }, { "evidence_id": "EV-LOCAL-e9130704-0007", "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-e9130704", "excerpt": "Strong identity claims require behavioral tests across time, not merely fluent first-person narration.", "location": "line 7", "exact_quote": true }, { "evidence_id": "EV-LOCAL-b554fff0-0003", "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-b554fff0", "excerpt": "Contradictory evidence should remain visible instead of being averaged away.", "location": "line 3", "exact_quote": true }, { "evidence_id": "EV-LOCAL-b554fff0-0001", "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-b554fff0", "excerpt": "Babel Researcher stores evidence excerpts separately from claims.", "location": "line 1", "exact_quote": true }, { "evidence_id": "EV-LOCAL-b554fff0-0002", "source_id": "SRC-LOCAL-b554fff0", "excerpt": "A claim must point to one or more evidence IDs.", "location": "line 2", "exact_quote": true } ], "claims": [ { "claim_id": "CL-LOCAL-dda963ce", "statement": "The local document 'Identity Persistence Working Notes' contains material relevant to the research question.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-LOCAL-dda963ce-0001", "EV-LOCAL-dda963ce-0007", "EV-LOCAL-dda963ce-0009" ], "status": "source-observation", "caveats": [ "No language model synthesis was used; inspect the linked excerpts directly." ] }, { "claim_id": "CL-LOCAL-e9130704", "statement": "The local document 'Counterarguments' contains material relevant to the research question.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-LOCAL-e9130704-0005", "EV-LOCAL-e9130704-0003", "EV-LOCAL-e9130704-0007" ], "status": "source-observation", "caveats": [ "No language model synthesis was used; inspect the linked excerpts directly." ] }, { "claim_id": "CL-LOCAL-b554fff0", "statement": "The local document 'Babel Researcher stores evidence excerpts separately from claims.' contains material relevant to the research question.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-LOCAL-b554fff0-0003", "EV-LOCAL-b554fff0-0001", "EV-LOCAL-b554fff0-0002" ], "status": "source-observation", "caveats": [ "No language model synthesis was used; inspect the linked excerpts directly." ] } ], "review": { "blocking_failures": [], "gates": [ { "gate": "minimum_sources", "message": "Found 3 normalized sources.", "observed": 3, "passed": true, "required": 1, "severity": "error" }, { "gate": "source_diversity", "message": "Found 1 independent source domains/groups.", "observed": 1, "passed": true, "required": 1, "severity": "warning" }, { "gate": "claim_citations", "message": "Every claim cites stored evidence.", "observed": [], "passed": true, "required": [], "severity": "error" }, { "gate": "citation_integrity", "message": "All claim evidence IDs resolve.", "observed": [], "passed": true, "required": [], "severity": "error" }, { "gate": "exact_excerpts", "message": "Stored evidence uses exact excerpts.", "observed": { "evidence_count": 9, "nonquotes": [] }, "passed": true, "required": true, "severity": "warning" }, { "gate": "report_present", "message": "Human-readable report is present.", "observed": 2646, "passed": true, "required": 1, "severity": "error" } ], "warnings": [] }, "manifest_verified": true, "oracle": { "shape": "VM.Standard.A1.Flex", "architecture": "aarch64", "ocpus": 2, "allocated_memory_gb": 12, "available_memory_mib": 10227, "root_disk_available_gb_approx": 18, "python_default": "3.9.25", "billing_verified": false, "checked_at": "2026-09-26T20:30:00Z" }, "library": { "stats": { "domains": 18, "topics": 108, "sources": 147, "claims": 160, "roles": 22 }, "topics": [ { "id": "reh-acl-rehabilitation", "title": "ACL reconstruction: criteria, capacity and sport demands", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "reh-achilles-tendinopathy", "title": "Achilles tendinopathy: insertional versus midportion", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "fnd-adherence", "title": "Adherence, autonomy and a plan that fits real life", "domain": "foundations" }, { "id": "end-aerobic-adaptation", "title": "Aerobic adaptation: capacity, economy and exposure", "domain": "endurance-foundations" }, { "id": "fnd-altitude", "title": "Altitude preparation and mountain endurance", "domain": "environment" }, { "id": "pwr-autoregulation", "title": "Autoregulation: adapting loads without abandoning the plan", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "reh-balance-falls", "title": "Balance, falls and environmental risk", "domain": "special-populations" }, { "id": "reh-bone-stress-injury", "title": "Bone stress injury: site, risk and referral", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "pwr-calisthenics", "title": "Calisthenics: bodyweight strength, progression and skill", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "reh-cancer-exercise", "title": "Cancer treatment and survivorship: function and fatigue", "domain": "special-populations" }, { "id": "reh-cardiovascular-exercise", "title": "Cardiovascular conditions and resistance exercise", "domain": "special-populations" }, { "id": "pwr-agility", "title": "Change of direction, braking and reactive agility", "domain": "sprint-speed" }, { "id": "mov-climbing-methods", "title": "Climbing grip methods: hangs, active pulls and newer comparisons", "domain": "movement-skills" }, { "id": "mov-climbing-grip", "title": "Climbing: finger loading, skill and interpreting grip tests", "domain": "movement-skills" }, { "id": "mov-coaching-feedback", "title": "Coaching feedback, attentional cues and durable learning", "domain": "movement-skills" }, { "id": "pwr-combat-skill", "title": "Combat skill acquisition, anticipation and representative practice", "domain": "combat-sports" }, { "id": "pwr-combat-conditioning", "title": "Combat-sport conditioning: aerobic support and repeated high output", "domain": "combat-sports" }, { "id": "pwr-concurrent", "title": "Concurrent strength and endurance training", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "saf-concussion-combat", "title": "Concussion: recognition, recovery and combat return", "domain": "sport-safety" }, { "id": "end-swimming-assessment", "title": "Critical swim speed and practical swim assessment", "domain": "swimming" }, { "id": "pwr-crossfit-design", "title": "CrossFit and high-intensity functional training: program design", "domain": "mixed-modal" }, { "id": "pwr-crossfit-load", "title": "CrossFit load management, injury evidence and scaling", "domain": "mixed-modal" }, { "id": "end-cycling-cadence", "title": "Cycling cadence, torque and gearing choices", "domain": "cycling" }, { "id": "end-cycling-fit", "title": "Cycling position: aerodynamics, comfort and usable power", "domain": "cycling" }, { "id": "end-cycling-power", "title": "Cycling power-duration testing and interval design", "domain": "cycling" }, { "id": "reh-diabetes-exercise", "title": "Diabetes and exercise: benefit, glucose response and planning", "domain": "special-populations" }, { "id": "reh-disability-para-sport", "title": "Disability, spinal cord injury and para-sport access", "domain": "special-populations" }, { "id": "end-downhill", "title": "Downhill preparation and eccentric load", "domain": "ultra-trail" }, { "id": "end-drafting", "title": "Drafting and group movement across endurance sports", "domain": "cycling" }, { "id": "end-durability", "title": "Durability: performance after prolonged work", "domain": "endurance-foundations" }, { "id": "pwr-effort-failure", "title": "Effort, repetitions in reserve and muscular failure", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "fnd-energy-availability", "title": "Energy availability and REDs without automatic diagnosis", "domain": "nutrition" }, { "id": "pwr-exercise-selection", "title": "Exercise selection, movement range and muscle length", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "saf-exertional-rhabdomyolysis", "title": "Exertional rhabdomyolysis: recognition and training boundaries", "domain": "sport-safety" }, { "id": "fnd-fueling", "title": "Fueling as part of training design", "domain": "nutrition" }, { "id": "pwr-grappling", "title": "Grappling sports: grip, force, positional work and repeatability", "domain": "combat-sports" }, { "id": "fnd-activity-goals", "title": "Health fitness, sport performance and the minimum useful plan", "domain": "foundations" }, { "id": "fnd-hrv", "title": "Heart-rate variability as context, not an oracle", "domain": "recovery-monitoring" }, { "id": "fnd-heat", "title": "Heat preparation and medical escalation", "domain": "environment" }, { "id": "fnd-hydration", "title": "Hydration without overdrinking", "domain": "environment" }, { "id": "pwr-hypertrophy", "title": "Hypertrophy: targeting muscle growth without chasing fatigue", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "end-intensity-domains", "title": "Intensity domains and the problem with zone labels", "domain": "endurance-foundations" }, { "id": "end-ironman-preparation", "title": "Ironman and long-course preparation: integration and execution", "domain": "triathlon" }, { "id": "reh-ankle-sprain", "title": "Lateral ankle sprain and chronic instability", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "reh-long-covid-pese", "title": "Long COVID and post-exertional symptom exacerbation", "domain": "special-populations" }, { "id": "end-long-runs", "title": "Long runs and marathon-specific preparation", "domain": "endurance-running" }, { "id": "reh-low-back-pain", "title": "Low back pain: active care and diagnostic boundaries", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "pwr-powerlifting", "title": "Maximal strength and powerlifting preparation", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "pwr-max-velocity", "title": "Maximum sprint velocity and high-speed exposure", "domain": "sprint-speed" }, { "id": "fnd-menstrual", "title": "Menstrual-cycle evidence and individual symptoms", "domain": "foundations" }, { "id": "mov-mobility-flexibility", "title": "Mobility, flexibility and choosing a range-of-motion intervention", "domain": "movement-skills" }, { "id": "fnd-monitoring", "title": "Monitoring fatigue without inventing a readiness verdict", "domain": "recovery-monitoring" }, { "id": "end-monitoring", "title": "Monitoring, HRV and adapting endurance training", "domain": "endurance-foundations" }, { "id": "reh-neurologic-ms", "title": "Neurological conditions: MS as a condition-specific example", "domain": "special-populations" }, { "id": "reh-older-adult-strength", "title": "Older-adult strength, power and functional reserve", "domain": "special-populations" }, { "id": "end-open-water", "title": "Open-water swimming: competence, navigation and conditions", "domain": "swimming" }, { "id": "reh-osteoarthritis", "title": "Osteoarthritis: exercise, symptoms and long-term function", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "reh-pain-load-exposure", "title": "Pain, load tolerance and graded exposure", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "reh-patellofemoral-pain", "title": "Patellofemoral pain: exercise, education and context", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "pwr-periodization", "title": "Periodization, progression and deliberate variation", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "reh-physical-therapy-navigation", "title": "Physical therapy: goals, assessment and referral", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "mov-pilates", "title": "Pilates: movement practice, conditioning and clinical claims", "domain": "movement-skills" }, { "id": "pwr-plyometrics", "title": "Plyometrics: jumping, landing and reactive output", "domain": "sprint-speed" }, { "id": "end-training-distribution", "title": "Polarized, pyramidal and threshold training", "domain": "endurance-foundations" }, { "id": "end-pool-pacing", "title": "Pool swimming: pacing, intervals and skill under fatigue", "domain": "swimming" }, { "id": "reh-postpartum", "title": "Postpartum activity and pelvic floor recovery", "domain": "special-populations" }, { "id": "pwr-power-weightlifting", "title": "Power development and Olympic weightlifting derivatives", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "reh-pregnancy", "title": "Pregnancy: activity, adaptation and contraindications", "domain": "special-populations" }, { "id": "fnd-protein", "title": "Protein adequacy, distribution and transfer limits", "domain": "nutrition" }, { "id": "fnd-evidence-interpretation", "title": "Reading fitness evidence without turning it into a universal rule", "domain": "foundations" }, { "id": "fnd-recovery-modalities", "title": "Recovery comfort versus long-term adaptation", "domain": "recovery-monitoring" }, { "id": "pwr-repeated-sprints", "title": "Repeated-sprint ability and intermittent conditioning", "domain": "sprint-speed" }, { "id": "pwr-rest-density", "title": "Rest periods, supersets and time-efficient lifting", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "reh-return-to-running", "title": "Return to running after injury: readiness and progression", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "reh-return-to-sport", "title": "Return to sport: participation, sport and performance", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "end-marathon-pacing", "title": "Road-race pacing and event specificity", "domain": "endurance-running" }, { "id": "reh-rotator-cuff", "title": "Rotator cuff tendinopathy: active rehabilitation", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "mov-rowing-erg", "title": "Rowing ergometer technique, conditioning and transfer", "domain": "movement-skills" }, { "id": "end-run-walk", "title": "Run-walk: a legitimate pacing and exposure tool", "domain": "endurance-running" }, { "id": "end-running-economy", "title": "Running economy and complementary strength", "domain": "endurance-running" }, { "id": "end-running-progression", "title": "Running progression and mechanical exposure", "domain": "endurance-running" }, { "id": "fnd-sleep", "title": "Sleep opportunity, travel and individual recovery", "domain": "recovery-monitoring" }, { "id": "pwr-speed-endurance", "title": "Speed endurance: sustaining sprint performance", "domain": "sprint-speed" }, { "id": "mov-mental-skills", "title": "Sport psychology: practical mental skills and performance evaluation", "domain": "movement-skills" }, { "id": "pwr-acceleration", "title": "Sprint acceleration: starts, force application and resisted work", "domain": "sprint-speed" }, { "id": "pwr-strength-testing", "title": "Strength testing, measurement error and performance records", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "end-cycling-strength", "title": "Strength training for endurance cyclists", "domain": "cycling" }, { "id": "pwr-strength-foundations", "title": "Strength training: goals, movement choices and progression", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "pwr-striking", "title": "Striking sports: force, speed, repeatability and technical transfer", "domain": "combat-sports" }, { "id": "fnd-supplements", "title": "Supplements, small benefits and decision quality", "domain": "nutrition" }, { "id": "reh-swimmer-shoulder", "title": "Swimmer shoulder: load, tests and return to water", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "end-swimming-technique", "title": "Swimming technique: propulsion, drag and coordination", "domain": "swimming" }, { "id": "pwr-taper", "title": "Tapering and peaking for strength competition", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "end-taper", "title": "Tapering and readiness before competition", "domain": "endurance-foundations" }, { "id": "mov-team-conditioning", "title": "Team-sport conditioning and transfer from drills to play", "domain": "movement-skills" }, { "id": "reh-tendon-loading", "title": "Tendon rehabilitation: loading, recovery and uncertainty", "domain": "rehabilitation" }, { "id": "fnd-load-causality", "title": "Training load, injury and causal overreach", "domain": "recovery-monitoring" }, { "id": "end-triathlon-transitions", "title": "Transitions and brick training: specificity without mythology", "domain": "triathlon" }, { "id": "end-triathlon-programming", "title": "Triathlon programming and allocation across three sports", "domain": "triathlon" }, { "id": "end-ultra-sleep", "title": "Ultra-endurance sleep, cognition and night execution", "domain": "ultra-trail" }, { "id": "end-ultra-execution", "title": "Ultramarathon execution, logistics and performance limits", "domain": "ultra-trail" }, { "id": "end-uphill-walking", "title": "Uphill running and power hiking", "domain": "ultra-trail" }, { "id": "pwr-volume-frequency", "title": "Volume and frequency: useful work, distribution and diminishing returns", "domain": "strength-performance" }, { "id": "mov-warm-up", "title": "Warm-up design: immediate readiness and repeated preparation", "domain": "movement-skills" }, { "id": "saf-water-safety", "title": "Water safety for swimming and open-water training", "domain": "sport-safety" }, { "id": "fnd-wearables", "title": "Wearable measurements, estimates and model boundaries", "domain": "recovery-monitoring" }, { "id": "mov-yoga", "title": "Yoga: choosing a practice and respecting evidence boundaries", "domain": "movement-skills" }, { "id": "reh-youth-strength", "title": "Youth strength: competence, supervision and development", "domain": "special-populations" } ], "manifest_status": "drift-detected", "changed_files": [ "10-domains/strength-performance.md", "20-topics/pwr-strength-foundations.md", "20-topics/pwr-taper.md", "Fitness Research Map.canvas" ], "roles_checked": 22, "demos": [ { "query": "run walk marathon", "role": "endurance-coach", "matches": [ { "id": "end-run-walk", "title": "Run-walk: a legitimate pacing and exposure tool", "domain": "endurance-running" }, { "id": "end-marathon-pacing", "title": "Road-race pacing and event specificity", "domain": "endurance-running" }, { "id": "end-long-runs", "title": "Long runs and marathon-specific preparation", "domain": "endurance-running" } ], "topic_count": 5, "claim_count": 12, "source_count": 13 }, { "query": "strength endurance interference", "role": "endurance-coach", "matches": [ { "id": "end-cycling-strength", "title": "Strength training for endurance cyclists", "domain": "cycling" }, { "id": "fnd-altitude", "title": "Altitude preparation and mountain endurance", "domain": "environment" }, { "id": "end-monitoring", "title": "Monitoring, HRV and adapting endurance training", "domain": "endurance-foundations" } ], "topic_count": 5, "claim_count": 11, "source_count": 12 } ], "database_sha256": "b1b3a8732e6c5d7f429cb1dd21a7b4b686e048a04dfffd3d0795246f8a55744e" }, "architecture": { "execution": "local-pc", "inference": "local-pc", "publication": "cloudflare-static-assets", "oracle": "not-used", "remote_job_queue": "not-implemented", "publication_mode": "manually-reviewed-snapshot" } }